It’s clear we won’t look for any sort of reconciliation between Hispanic and Native American history buffs anytime soon. The explosive remarks made by local history teacher Roberto Valdez and San Elizario (Texas) Historical District Director Al Borrego July 13 at the Española Valley Fiesta will surely not go unchallenged by many Native Americans angry about celebrating Don Juan de Oñate.

    San Elizario is a small community just southeast of El Paso. It has a historic district with shops and restaurants. We’re jealous, but we digress.

    The long and tiring argument has each side claiming revisionist history by the opposing side. Hispanics want to celebrate and embrace their history as Spanish conquerors. Native Americans want the alleged atrocities acknowledged and (who knows) apologized for? Then let’s stop celebrating Oñate, who may or may not have done many different things claimed by both sides.

    This politically correct argument simmered for a long time. It came to a boil a few years ago when Indians from several local pueblos demonstrated at Santa Fe’s annual fiesta. In that instance they were arguing about Don Diego de Vargas, who took Santa Fe back from the Indians in 1692. (or they welcomed him back?) Again, atrocities alleged, denied, argued repeatedly.

    We don’t mean to make light of the actually history. It’s important. The continued fighting over it is not. The adage history is written by the victors goes a long way here.

    Valdez and Borrego were basing their comments on transcripts written by Oñate’s soldiers and senior staff. In recounting the settling of the Española Valley, surely they’re going to go a little light on the rape and torture stories and keep to the diplomatic side of Spaniards mixing with Indians and cumbaya.

    In Borrego’s case, he claimed Acoma Pueblo elders told him 8,000 Acoma people were killed in 1599 by Oñate. He probably rightly said there weren’t 8,000 people living there at the time. He then rehashed Oñate cutting off feet of some (still a soft number) Acoma men and a woman being raped.

    Borrego minimizes the rape and torture with, “All they did was cut the foot off. They could have killed them.” Good news all around.

    Valdez openly questioned the veracity of the Acoma elders’ statements. “I remain skeptical that today’s Acoma, who are antagonistic, are telling the truth,” he said.

    Both sides claim to cite historic fact. The problem is it’s fairly simple to find transcripts, letters and journals to support either side’s argument.

    Also both sides must acknowledge that fighting of any sort is brutal. Whether with knives, arrows, clubs and muskets or hand grenades, automatic weapons and tanks, the result is the same: death and destruction. War brings out the worst in everyone. If someone isn’t fighting for their life, they’ve watched friends die and maintain a razor sharp hatred for the group responsible.

    The ridiculous marketing catch phrase, “Where Cultures Unite,” remains just as divisive today as in Oñate’s 1599 or DeVargas’s 1692. There’s no answer here. We have a group of people who insist on celebrating Oñate, or sugarcoat it by claiming they are celebrating the Spanish arrival. By celebrating them they rub it in local Indians' faces.

    Opposing them are people whose ancestors lost land, lives and most of their rights. They can’t prosecute, try and punish Oñate or DeVargas, but 400 years later they can keep that grudge going and try to make life miserable for anyone who recognizes early Spanish conquerors.

    We understand the anger to a degree but the hypocrisy must be recognized. The Spanish arrival here  began a whole new way of life, beginning with acequias, new seeds, animals farming techniques, iron work, mapping, building, which took us into the industrial age and eventually where we are today.

    You can't drive a car, shop at a grocery store or be glued to an iPhone and not appreciate where that technology began.

    Valdez and Borrego did nothing to move things along in a healthy, open manner. They clearly took us back a decade or two.

(3) comments

Talkingice

Valdez and Borrego (an amateur historian ) not even a PH.D can’t provide credibility to what has already been proven by true educated historians. Watch ”Surviving Columbus” creditable details, providing specifics to the horrors that Onate and his thugs did to natives.

NMConservative

If memory and science serve me correctly....I do believe that so called "Native Americans", aren't native to the Americas. It is of historical fact and science that the first Americans (Native American ancestors), trecked from Siberia across the Bering Land Bridge. So whether you walked by land bridge to the Americas or sailed by Spanish ship, we must be cognizant of the facts before wanting to extinguish a people's history and culture.

Jo Jo

What hypocrisy! To understand, the city council voted to repeal the fiesta ordinance, only to have a councilor (John Vigil) sit as president of the newly formed nonprofit responsible for the planning and executing this year’s Fiesta? Further, Why do we have someone from San Elizario come here and lecture us on our history? Was this “history lesson” planned by JV? The mayor, considering he is from around that area? Lastly, I mean really, the people that hold Don Juan Oñate praise this guy so much for them to hold Oñate higher than, dare I say it, God. I digress. Funny thing is that these same people swear they are pure Spaniard. The hypocrisy

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.