It’s good to have a little star power on your side. This wasn’t the case Sunday when Robert Redford wrote a column for the Santa Fe New Mexican.

    Redford refers to himself as an activist and his many appearances over the years prop up that label. His Sunday column was about the greatly debated Verde Transmission Line, almost all of which runs through Rio Arriba County.

    We had a few problems with his prose, aside from the fact he was writing to a Santa Fe audience about a mostly Rio Arriba County issue.

    The first issue we have with almost all celebrities is that when they want to wade into an issue, they try to sell themselves as local. Redford claims to be a 36-year resident of Santa Fe. We don’t doubt he owns property there but does that make him a resident in the same sense most people use the word resident? Not likely.

    He can also probably claim to be a resident of Park City, Utah and Los Angeles, Calif. That claim would be fair in the sense the state statute addresses residency. In the case of candidate and voter residency, a location can be called a residence if the person intends to return there one day to live.

    The big issue we must take up with Redford is his total acceptance of allowing pueblos to use their land in any way they see fit.

    We understand the sovereignty issue very well. Pueblos are allowed to do whatever they wish with their land. However, a reasonable person would talk to their neighbors before allowing a huge (unneeded) power line to run through three pueblos resulting in a battle to stop the line on Bureau of Land Management property.

    None of the pueblos have demonstrated any sort of desire or will to be those good neighbors. They’re strictly out to improve their respective tribal councils’ coffers. They’re not subject to any sort of review and are not accountable to tribal members. Unscientifically and anecdotally speaking, most tribal members are against the Verde Transmission Line. But they have no voice on tribal councils.

    The pueblos have put everyone outside of pueblo boundaries on the defensive in regard to the Verde Transmission Line, all in the name of making a buck. We acknowledge it’s a lot of bucks, but that doesn’t make it right.

    We’ll not see the Española Valley improve until many things change. One of those things is Indian pueblos working with the city of Española and Rio Arriba County. Ramming a power line down everyone’s collective throat is not neighborly and will blight pueblo and non-pueblo property.

    A dollar seems to trump Indians’ claims to the sacred land from which they come. How can running power lines over ancestral land be acceptable?

    The power line will not lower power costs for anyone, including pueblo residents. None of us in Rio Arriba County will see any benefit from the line, save tribal councils.

    For Redford to flippantly state he agrees with pueblos’ rights to do with their land what they wish is to assume we all live in a vacuum. In this era of global repercussions we are even more interconnected, especially when it comes to water, power, energy drilling and pollution. Surely Redford wouldn’t agree it’s fine for Mexico to put manufacturing plants eight miles south of the U.S./Mexico border? Mexico has the right to do so but it’s not ethically or morally right.

    We don’t expect the pueblos to come to their senses and see past the dollar signs, but bringing a celebrity stamp of approval into things doesn’t help the matter. A good environmental activist would oppose a useless power line such as the Verde Transmission Line, period. To say it’s OK for Indians but not for non-Indians is disingenuous.

    That would also hold true in Park City, Utah, where Redford “resides.”

(6) comments

Give me a break

The word "sovereign" is thrown around whenever any pueblo wants to engage in an activity with no regard for their neighbors, and if I have to hear about their "ancient ancestral sacred lands" one more time, I'm going to throw up. Drive thru any pueblo and tell me how they "respect their lands" while you look at trash, broken down cars, etc.

Bruno

I say play nice or seriously boycott!!! without the financial support from the valley ALL pueblo businesses would go bankrupt!!! I say BOYCOTT!!!!

FP

Reporter needed:
I have heard that the board of the Jacona Land Grant has also made an agreement with Hunt for going through a part of their land with the proposed $Verde$ project, and most of the members of that group are not aware of this. This needs to be verified.
Apparently all agreements with Hunt have been made confidentially so no one knows the amount of money involved or what might be shared amongst the members of these four communities.
The divisive nature of this situation is what is most unacceptable, aside from the power lines themselves.
We have a unique opportunity here to unite together against corporate greed and unethical behavior.

Glenn

You take issue with Mr. Redford's residency status claim. I would venture to say that you have absolutely no idea where his residence(s) may be. Further, if a person has more than one home, does that disqualify them from being a resident of any place because they have a choice of where to rest their heads at night? You question the validity of his concern about Santa Fe, where he claims residency and then chastise him because most of the line runs through Rio Arriba County. Would you still make issue of his residency if he had mentioned that? Or would you get even more miffed because he owns NO property in Rio Arriba? "You're no local, you're from Santa!"

He states that he doesn't support this project. He, like you and I, has no say on tribal lands so why not concentrate on land where we have a voice, and as he pointed out, already have had our say through the BLM Master Plan Process.

Celebrities are easy targets, some deservedly so. But Redford has a decades long record for caring about public lands and the environment. He brought more attention to the Verde line's questionable process with the BLM instantly and widely. For you to nitpick about his position against the line, which I recall being the same as your paper's, reads like a cheap shot because it's easy to take jabs at the famous to garner attention.

sirigian

How about if we support the residents of our Pueblos to become fully franchised participants in all the decision making as was their traditional role, and encouraging their leaders to invest in projects that not only help them, but also are useful and a point of pride for the rest of us. Some ideas might be: creating a marketing strategy that entices the movie industry to use their incredibly beautiful land short term, bringing tourists--perhaps to a Los Golondrinas type of ancient Pueblo education center, pilgrimage to potently sacred Black Mesa, etc. Let's help one another all 'round! Fighting hurts us all, and encourages hurtful "fight-back."

Glenn

Well said. No matter the outcome, if we don't try to work together, there will be lasting ill will.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.